diff --git a/src/main/java/kcc/kccadr/aprvl/service/impl/AprvlMgrServiceImpl.java b/src/main/java/kcc/kccadr/aprvl/service/impl/AprvlMgrServiceImpl.java
index 41cf263e..c0e34881 100644
--- a/src/main/java/kcc/kccadr/aprvl/service/impl/AprvlMgrServiceImpl.java
+++ b/src/main/java/kcc/kccadr/aprvl/service/impl/AprvlMgrServiceImpl.java
@@ -328,14 +328,18 @@ public class AprvlMgrServiceImpl  extends EgovAbstractServiceImpl implements Apr
 			adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.setWhereQuery("	AND	agnt_sbmt_id='ID2'	");
 			adrSbmtMgrHstryService.deleteWithQuery(adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO);				
 
-			//step4.이력 정보 남기기 처리를 해야 한다.	I - adr_sbmt_mgr_hstry
-			this._insertAdrSbmtMgrHstry(
-					adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO
-					, aprvlMgrVO
-					, "ID2"
-					, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbsttSbmtId2()
-					, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbmtId2()
-					);
+			if (!"".equals(adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbsttSbmtId2())) {
+				//대결자가 있는 경우만 이력을 남긴다.
+				//step4.이력 정보 남기기 처리를 해야 한다.	I - adr_sbmt_mgr_hstry
+				this._insertAdrSbmtMgrHstry(
+						adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO
+						, aprvlMgrVO
+						, "ID2"
+						, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbsttSbmtId2()
+						, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbmtId2()
+						);
+			}
+
 		}
 		
 		if ("A".equals(adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbmtYn3())) {	//1단계 결재 전임
@@ -349,14 +353,18 @@ public class AprvlMgrServiceImpl  extends EgovAbstractServiceImpl implements Apr
 			adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.setWhereQuery("	AND	agnt_sbmt_id='ID3'	");
 			adrSbmtMgrHstryService.deleteWithQuery(adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO);				
 
-			//step4.이력 정보 남기기 처리를 해야 한다.	I - adr_sbmt_mgr_hstry
-			this._insertAdrSbmtMgrHstry(
-					adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO
-					, aprvlMgrVO
-					, "ID3"
-					, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbsttSbmtId3()
-					, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbmtId3()
-					);
+			if (!"".equals(adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbsttSbmtId3())) {
+				//대결자가 있는 경우만 이력을 남긴다.
+				//step4.이력 정보 남기기 처리를 해야 한다.	I - adr_sbmt_mgr_hstry
+				this._insertAdrSbmtMgrHstry(
+						adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO
+						, aprvlMgrVO
+						, "ID3"
+						, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbsttSbmtId3()
+						, adrSbmtLineMgrUsrVO.getSbmtId3()
+						);				
+			}
+
 		}
 		
 		//step2.기존 이력 데이터를 모두 삭제하고	D - adr_sbmt_mgr_hstry